When remodeling a bathroom, one of the biggest decisions is choosing between a bathtub vs shower stall. Both options have advantages and drawbacks, depending on your needs, space, and budget. Some people prefer a relaxing soak, while others prioritize efficiency and accessibility.
This guide explores different bathtub and shower stall types, costs, and key factors to help you decide which is best for your home.
Bathtubs: Styles and Benefits
Bathtubs offer comfort and relaxation, making them a popular choice for homeowners. They are ideal for unwinding after a long day and are also useful for families with young children.
There are several types of bathtubs to choose from:
Alcove Bathtub: This is the most common option. It fits between three walls and often includes a shower, making it a space-efficient choice.
Freestanding Bathtub: This stylish tub stands alone and serves as a centerpiece in modern bathrooms. It requires more floor space but adds elegance.
Clawfoot Bathtub: Known for its classic design, this tub has decorative feet and a vintage feel. It takes up more space but adds charm.
Soaking Tub: Deeper than a standard tub, this design allows for full-body immersion and is great for relaxation.
Jetted Tub: A high-end option with built-in water jets that provide a spa-like experience. It costs more and requires maintenance.
Pros of a Bathtub
- Perfect for relaxation
- Ideal for families with small children
- Increases home value in some markets
Cons of a Bathtub
- Takes up more space than a shower stall
- Uses more water than a shower
- Can be difficult to step in and out of, especially for older adults
Shower Stalls: Styles and Benefits
A shower stall is a space-saving and efficient option. It allows for quick showers, conserves water, and provides easy access for people with mobility issues.
There are different types of shower stalls available:
Prefabricated Shower Stall: A ready-made unit that is easy to install. It is a budget-friendly option for quick renovations.
Walk-In Shower: A sleek, doorless design that enhances accessibility. It works well in modern bathrooms.
Corner Shower: A compact stall that fits into a corner, making it ideal for small bathrooms.
Frameless Glass Shower: A stylish option with clear glass panels that create a spacious feel. It requires more cleaning to maintain its look.
Steam Shower: A luxury choice that doubles as a steam room, providing health benefits but at a higher cost.
Pros of a Shower Stall
- Saves water compared to a bathtub
- Takes up less space, making it ideal for small bathrooms
- Easier to clean and maintain
- Provides better accessibility for seniors and people with mobility challenges
Cons of a Shower Stall
- Not ideal for bathing children
- May reduce resale value in some markets
- Can feel less luxurious than a bathtub
Cost Comparison
Budget is a major factor when deciding between a bathtub vs shower. The price depends on the type of installation and materials used.
A basic alcove bathtub is one of the most affordable options, ranging from $500 to $2,500, while freestanding tubs can cost anywhere from $1,200 to $5,000. More luxurious choices, like jetted tubs, can exceed $7,000, especially when factoring in installation costs.
Shower stalls vary in price as well. Prefabricated shower stalls are the most budget-friendly, starting at $500, while custom walk-in showers with frameless glass can cost $2,000 to $8,000. Steam showers are among the most expensive, often exceeding $10,000.
If cost is a major concern, a prefabricated shower stall or an alcove bathtub is the most economical option.
Water Usage and Efficiency
Water consumption is another important consideration. A bathtub vs shower debate often includes environmental and cost concerns.
A standard bathtub holds 35 to 50 gallons of water per bath. In contrast, a 10-minute shower with a low-flow showerhead uses 20 to 25 gallons of water.
For households looking to save on water bills, a shower stall is the better option. However, if someone takes long showers, the difference in water usage may be minimal.
Accessibility Considerations
For seniors or people with mobility challenges, a shower stall is usually the better choice. A walk-in shower with no curb allows for easy entry and exit, reducing the risk of falls. Many walk-in showers also include grab bars and built-in seating for added safety.
Bathtubs, on the other hand, can be difficult to step into. Walk-in bathtubs exist, but they are more expensive than standard options. If aging in place is a priority, a shower stall is the most practical solution.
Resale Value
Resale value is another factor to consider. In some markets, a house without a bathtub may not appeal to families with young children. Many buyers prefer to have at least one bathtub in the home.
However, modern walk-in showers can attract buyers looking for a sleek and updated bathroom. The best solution is to have both a bathtub and a shower if space allows. If that’s not possible, consider the needs of potential buyers in your area before making a final decision.
Which Option Is Best for You?
Choosing between a bathtub vs shower depends on personal preference and practical needs.
A bathtub is the better choice if you:
- Enjoy long, relaxing soaks
- Have small children who need bathing
- Want to increase resale value in a family-friendly market
A shower stall is the better choice if you:
- Have limited space in your bathroom
- Want to save water and reduce utility costs
- Need better accessibility for aging or mobility issues
The decision between a bathtub vs shower comes down to lifestyle, budget, and future plans. A bathtub offers relaxation and traditional appeal, while a shower stall saves space and conserves water.
Consider your daily routine, the needs of your household, and any long-term plans when making your choice. Both options have their own advantages, but the best choice is the one that fits your lifestyle.
Would you choose a bathtub or a shower stall for your next bathroom renovation? Please share your thoughts in the comments!